A few weeks back I had a conversation with my brother about this idea I’ve been playing with for a while. The gist of it is this, which is better; a homogeneous mix of peoples of all diversities and types or a total segregation? Oil and vinegar or thousand island dressing?
After getting over the whole impossibility of either extreme, just from a logistical point of view, we kind of agreed that a clumpy mixture halfway in between pure blend and total separation is probably not only best but also the balance point that humans and their society are naturally going to grow towards.
Today I was listening to Dan Carlin’s Common Sense podcast about how it seems like the political situation in the States is getting kinda depressing, where we are so different that it barely seems worth the fight to come together. And when he brought up the idea of states seceding, I started thinking that it was perhaps time for me to get a copy of the fabulous Mr. Tom Merritt‘s Boiling Point. And that I feel like it would both be best for the country (hell, for the whole world) if the US split up into little state countries and that it would also be utterly horrible, leading to segregation, hate, and repression.
Okay, to explain a little bit. First off, Tom’s book Boiling Point is about the future when the US isn’t so united anymore because states have been breaking off into their own independent countries. Or at least that’s the impression I have, since I haven’t actually read the story yet.
I like the idea of breaking the US up because I realize that freedom for me means that everyone gets to believe whatever bullshit they believe. I’m not sure how to articulate this idea fully, but the idea is that while I find people who disagree with same sex marriage repugnant, I also believe that their freedom to believe (wrongly) is being impinged when we do the right thing and bring equal rights to all. If, for example, South Carolinian (I chose them ‘cuz I hate SC) decides to disallow homosexuality and, why not, colored people (including those damn no good injuns)…
Yeah, see, I can’t even make the argument FOR breaking up without devolving into why it is a terrible idea.
So extend this further. If we mandate freedom for all on people who don’t believe in freedom for all, don’t we dimish their freedom? But isn’t it the greater evil to not allow the equal freedom for all? So shouldn’t we be out busting up other countries to MAKE FORCE them to have freedom for all also?
I mean, that sounds like an obvious wrong idea, but isn’t that what we did as a country in the civil war? Aren’t we all rpoud of ourselves for forccing the south to stay in the country, for forcing them to become “better people”? So doesn’t it follow that we should continue to FORCE betterment?
Doesn’t that lead to double ungood?
I’m so fed up with the fear mongering, hate, and lies in goverment, but.. well, what do I expect from a gigantic group of humans animals who can barely remember to think even some of the time?